Shekar · a moment, addressed

My portfolio just dropped 20% — should I sell?

How to think clearly when everything is red and every instinct screams sell

Section 0 · Real moments4 min readFirst-time investorPublished
A warm, brightly lit Indian kirana shop bustling with business inside while it rains on the street outside.
My portfolio dropped 20% — should I sell?

When everything looks red, your instinct screams to sell. But is it the right move?

You opened the app this morning expecting nothing. Everything was red. The portfolio you've been building for three years shows a loss that feels like a punch. Your thumb is hovering over the sell button.

Ramesh
Market is down 20%! I am selling everything before it hits zero. You should too!

First, breathe. A 20% portfolio drop feels catastrophic. But the Sensex has seen at least 8 corrections of 20% or more since 1991, and recovered from every single one.

The price you see today is not the value of the business. It is what a nervous market is offering you right now. Those are two very different things.

Before you touch the sell button, ask one honest question: has the business actually changed? Lower profits? A broken product? Debt it cannot repay? Or has only the price moved?

Selling locks the loss permanently. It removes your right to the recovery. Staying — in a fundamentally sound investment — keeps the full upside available to you.

SENSEX 20%+ DROPS SINCE 1991
8
Every single one recovered to hit new all-time highs
Analogy

The neighbour who quotes you a price every day

Imagine you own a small share of a kirana shop with a neighbour. Every morning he knocks and offers to buy your share — or sell you more. Some mornings he's euphoric and quotes a very high price. Some mornings he's terrified and quotes far less. The shop's daily sales haven't changed at all. Only his mood has. A market fall is your neighbour having a bad week. You don't have to accept his price.

Enter the percentage your portfolio is down. The widget shows exactly how much gain you need to get back to zero — and how many years at India's historical market return before you're whole again.

The Recovery Calculator

Gain needed just to break even0%
Before the fall₹1 lakh
After the drop₹80,000
After staying invested₹1.1 lakh

A 20% drop takes ₹1 lakh to ₹80,000. To break even, you need a 25% gain, not 20%. Selling locks in the loss. If you stay invested for 3 years at an illustrative 12% rate, your portfolio grows to ₹1.1 lakh.

Why this matters

When your portfolio is red, every notification feels urgent. But the decision you make in the next five minutes can follow you for a decade. The question is never 'how do I stop losing?' It's 'is the business I own still sound?' If yes — the price tag on your investment has changed. The investment itself has not.

Where people go wrong

  1. Selling at the bottom and waiting for clarityClarity never arrives. The market hits new highs while you wait on the sidelines for certainty that does not exist.
  2. Treating a falling price as a failing businessPrice and value are not the same thing. A business earning well today earns well regardless of what the market quotes.
  3. Checking the portfolio app every few hours during a fallMore checks do not improve the decision. They amplify panic and shrink your thinking horizon from years to minutes.
  4. Averaging down without first re-checking your original thesisAdding to a falling position is only smart if the original reason to own it is still valid. Check first, act second.
If you only remember three things

  1. A 20% fall needs a 25% gain to recover — selling and re-entering digs the hole deeper.

  2. Every Sensex bear market since 1991 has recovered and gone on to hit new all-time highs.

  3. Before selling, ask one question: has the business changed, or only the price?

Loss aversion means a paper loss feels twice as painful as an equivalent gain feels good. That is why the urge to sell feels like self-protection. Most of the time, it is self-destruction in disguise.
Shekar

More moments

21

Someone just told me to buy this stock

4 min

I have ₹50,000. Where do I put it?

5 min

F&O looks like easy money — is it?

5 min

I want to start investing. Where do I begin?

5 min

My stock is up 40% — should I book profits?

4 min

I just got my first salary. What now?

4 min

My parents want me to buy LIC. Should I?

5 min

Should I prepay the home loan or invest?

5 min

Is an FD safer than stocks?

4 min

Is gold a better investment than stocks?

4 min

Is real estate a better investment than stocks?

5 min

What about crypto? Bitcoin, Ethereum, all that

5 min

I'm 25. I have no idea what to do with money

5 min

I just inherited money. What do I do?

6 min

I'm getting married — what about joint finances?

6 min

EPF, NPS, PPF — which one is for me?

6 min

Everyone's applying for this IPO — should I?

5 min

How banks and "RMs" mis-sell products to you

5 min

I have credit-card debt. Should I still invest?

4 min

My stock has done nothing for three years. Should I exit?

5 min

The stock I bought is down 50%. Now what?

5 min